Updated 04-I-2018

Dr. Archie Garfield Worthing

This article is based on a document of fellow lamp engineer and collector Edward J. Covington, which appeared on his website of biographical sketches of persons involved in the lamp industry. Following his passing in February 2017 and with kind permission of his family, Ed's words have been preserved and subsequently expanded with new material by this author, to maintain continued access to the research he initiated.


Dr. Archie Garfield Worthing4

Biography
Certain consumer products appear simple in structure and can mislead one into thinking that they are therefore easy to manufacture. The electric incandescent lamp is one such product, but it is deceiving in that considerable study of some of the elements of the product are required for commercial success to occur. The engineering and scientific studies regarding tungsten, the light giving element of the lamp, are beyond the ability to imagine.

Those persons knowledgeable in the early work carried out with tungsten are familiar with the names of Herbert Ives, (a href="http://www.lamptech.co.uk/Documents/People%20-%20Forsythe%20WE.htm">William Forsythe and William Coolidge, as well as the name of A. G. Worthing. These persons deserve some of the credit for the success of lamp products eventually developed by engineers, chemists and physicists.

Archie Garfield Worthing was born on 6 February 1881 in LeRoy, Dodge County, Wisconsin, being the son of Loella (McKnight) Worthing (1857-1919) and Arthur James Worthing (1855-1934). He obtained his B.A. degree from the University of Wisconsin in 1904. The Ph.D. degree was earned at the University of Michigan in 1911. Worthing then took a job at the newly created laboratory of the National Works in Cleveland in 1911.

Although working on practical lamp design problems was not the usual kind of activity undertaken by Worthing, there were exceptions during World War I. Quoting from The National in the World War1:

"Early in 1918 the Laboratory was asked to develop an artificial-light unit for signalling in the daytime in places where the operator would be seen against a bright sky background. Later an additional request came for a 6-volt, 2-ampere lamp for use in a trench-signalling unit designed by Major Mendenhall and the Lynn Works of General Electric Company, to supplant the unsatisfactory unit then in service. Practically the entire time of Drs. Forsythe, Lorenz and Worthing was given for a period of ten or twelve months to working out these problems in light-signalling."
In regard to the above the following was also said1:
"A 2-ampere, 6-volt, G-12 D. C. bayonet S-4 filament Mazda C lamp was developed for the trench signal unit for Major Mendenhall by the Lamp Development Laboratory and Dr. Worthing; lamps were supplied through the Lynn Works of the G. E. Co., for 300 units."
As will become evident when the reader scans the works published by Worthing (some of which are listed below), he contributed an enormous amount of important technical data so that the tungsten filament lamp could attain the prominent place in lighting that has endured since about 1909. He continued to add to that wealth of information after he left Nela Park and settled down at the University of Pittsburgh. Some lifetime activities of A. G. Worthing are shown below in time sequence.
Teacher in grammar school, Brandon, WI, 1900-1901
Earned a bachelor of arts degree from the University of Wisconsin in 1904
Assistant in physics, University of Wisconsin, 1904-1906
Acting instructor in physics, State University of Iowa, Iowa City, 1906-1909
Earned a doctorate degree from the University of Michigan in 1911
Associate physicist, Physical Laboratory of National Lamp Works, Cleveland, OH, 1911-1914
Physicist, Nela Research Laboratories, Cleveland, OH, 1914-1925
Head of Physics Department, University of Pittsburgh, 1925-1937
Professor of physics at the University of Pittsburgh since 1925
Vice-President of the American Association of Physics Teachers, 1940
President of the American Association of Physics Teachers, 1941
Fellow of the American Physical Society
Vice-President of the Optical Society of America, 1939-1941
President of the Optical Society of America, 1941-1942
Member of the board of governors of the American Institute of Physics since 1941
Member of Phi Beta Kappa, Sigma Xi and Sigma Pi Sigma
The A. G. Worthing Award is given annually to the outstanding senior in Physics at the University of Pittsburgh.

Some clarification should be made regarding the Physical Laboratory of National Lamp Works and the Nela Research Laboratories mentioned above. These are simply early names of what became known as the headquarters for General Electric Lighting at Nela Park in East Cleveland, Ohio. National became part of the General Electric organization in 1911.

Worthing married Exie Lillian Witherbee on 23 June 1905. Their children were Marion (b ca 1911), Helen (b ca 1917) and Robert (b 1918). Additional information regarding ancestors and descendants can be found at the very end of this write-up. Dr. Worthing passed away on 30 July 1949, four days after an abdominal operation.

A tribute to A. G. Worthing was published by O. H. Blackwood3. In the Blackwood article some of Worthing's personal characteristics were noted. Colleagues of Worthing pointed out that he had a passion for accuracy with meticulous attention to detail. He was sure-minded and in his teaching of physics his goal was to make sure that every student had comprehension of the material being taught. Worthing strived to improve one's ability to express and think problems through clearly.




Acknowledgements
The writer is grateful to be able to include a photograph of Dr. Worthing in this writing; the photograph was scanned from Reference 4. The Cincinnati and Hamilton County Public Library was generous to provide a photocopy of Reference 3 for my use. The writer benefited greatly from email messages, as well as a telephone call, from Leigh Larson, who has a website titled "Olive W. Larson." Olive W. Larson6 was the daughter-in-law of Archie G. Worthing. Mr. Larson communicated much genealogy information in which the Larson family is related to the Worthing's. The descendant chart at the tail end of this writing is due to the present writer however, and any errors in information on the chart are mine alone.


Publications - Articles
  1. "Some Thermodynamic Properties of Air and of Carbon Dioxide", A. G. Worthing, Thesis/dissertation, Publisher: Lancaster, Pennsylvania, The New Era, 1911.
  2. "A Study of the Energy Losses in Electric Incandescent Lamps", E. P. Hyde, F. E. Cady, A. G. Worthing, Transactions of the Illuminating Engineering Society, Vol.6, p.238, 1911.
  3. "The Ratio of the Two Heat Capacities of Carbon Dioxide as a Function of the Pressure and the Temperature", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Series 1, Vol.32, pp.243-245, 1911.
  4. "On the Deviation from Lambert's Cosine Law of the Emission from Tungsten and Carbon at Glowing Temperatures", A. G. Worthing, Astrophysical Journal, Vol.36, p.345, 1912.
  5. "Some Effects of Diffraction on Brightness Measurements Made with the Holbornkurlbaum Optical Pyrometer", A. G. Worthing & W. E. Forsythe, Physical Review, Vol.3, pp.494-496, 1914; also Vol.4, pp.163-176, 1914.
  6. "Temperature Distribution in an Incandescent Lamp Filament in the Neighborhood of a Cooling Junction", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.4, pp.524-534, 1914.
  7. "The Thermal Conductivites of Tungsten, Tantalum and Carbon at Incandescent Temperatures by an Optical Pyrometer Method," A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.4, pp.35-543, 1914.
  8. "The Thomson Effects in Tungsten, Tantalum and Carbon at Incandescent Temperatures Determined by an Optical Pyrometer Method", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.5, pp.445-451, 1915.
  9. "The Ballistic Use of a Moving-Coil Galvanometer in Measuring Discharges Obeying the Exponential Decay Law", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.6, pp.165-179, 1915.
  10. "The True Temperature Scale for Tungsten and Its Emissive Powers at Incandescent Temperatures", A.G. Worthing, Journal of the Franklin Institute, Vol.81, pp.417-418, 1916.
  11. "Effect of Diffraction on Brightness Measurements", A. G. Worthing & W. E. Forsythe, Abstract-Bulletin, Nela Research Laboratory, p.140, 1917.
  12. "Over-Shooting" in Tungsten Lamps", A. G. Worthing, Abstract-Bulletin, Nela Research Laboratory, p.209, 1917.
  13. "Rating Lamps as to Filament Brightness with Fluctuating Voltages", A. G. Worthing, Abstract-Bulletin, Nela Research Laboratory, p.215, 1917.
  14. "The True Temperature Scale of Tungsten and its Emissive Powers at Incandescent Temperature", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.10, pp.377-394, 1917.
  15. "The Thermal Expansion of Tungsten at Incan-Descent Temperatures", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.10, pp.638-641, 1917.
  16. "Atomic Heats of Tungsten and of Carbon at Incandescent Temperatures", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.12, pp.199-225, 1918. Also Journal of the Franklin Institute, pp.707-708, 1918.
  17. "Emissive Powers and Temperature of Non-black Bodies", A. G. Worthing, Bulletin of the American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical Engineers, pp.367-399, 1920. Also pp.1895-1927.
  18. "Pulsating Thermionic Discharges in Evacuated Tungsten Lamps", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.17, p.237-238, 1921.
  19. Effect of Strong Electrostatic Fields on the Vaporization of Tungsten", A. G. Worthing & W. C. Baker, Physical Review, Vol.17, pp.239-240, 1921.
  20. Total Emissive Power and Resistivities of W at Incandescence", A. G. Worthing & W. E. Forsythe, Physical Review, Vol.18, p.144, 1921.
  21. "Theory of End-Loss Corrections and Its Application to Uniform, Electrically Heated Tungsten Filaments in Vacuo", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Franklin Institute, Vol.194, pp.597-611, 1922.
  22. A. G. Worthing, Bulletin Nela Research Laboratory, Vol.1, pp.338, 349, 1922.
  23. "Two Modifications of the Simple Drum Type Potentiometer and a Design for a Double Potentiometer", A. G. Worthing & W. E. Forsythe, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.10, pp.599-602, 1925.
  24. "The Properties of Tungsten and the Characteristics of Tungsten Lamps", W. E. Forsythe & A. G. Worthing, The Astrophysical Journal, Vol.61, pp.146-185, 1925.
  25. "The Temperature Scale and the Melting Point of Molybdenum", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.25, pp 846-857, 1925.
  26. "Deviation from Lambert's Law and Polarization of Light Emitted by Incandescent Tungsten, Tantalum and Molybdenum and Changes in the Optical Constants of Tungsten with Temperature", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.13, pp.635-647, 1926.
  27. "Spectral Emissivities of Tantalum, Platinum, Nickel and Gold as a Function of Temperature, and the Melting Point of Tantalum", A. G. Worthing,Physical Review, Vol.28, pp.174-189, 1926.
  28. "Physical Properties of Well Seasoned Molybdenum and Tantalum as a Function of Temperature", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.28, pp.190-201, 1926.
  29. "On the Effect of High Electrostatic Fields on the Vaporization of Metals", A. G. Worthing, Physical Review, Vol.43, p.383, 1933.
  30. "Usefulness of Objective Physics Tests of the Reasoning Type", A. G. Worthing, The American Physics Teacher, Vol.1, pp.6-10, 1933.
  31. "Simple Test for the Preciseness of a Definition of a Physical Term or Quantity", A. G. Worthing, The American Physics Teacher, Vol.6, pp.59-61, 1938.
  32. "Determination of Optical Constants with the Aid of an Optical Pyrometer", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.28, pp.311-312, 1938.
  33. "Radiation Laws Describing the Emission of Photons by Black Bodies", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.29, pp.97-100, 1939.
  34. "New λT Relations for Black Body Radiation", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.29, pp.101-101, 1939.
  35. "Temperature Concept", A. G. Worthing, American Journal of Physics, Vol.8, pp.28-29, 1940.
  36. "Total Hemispherical Emissivities by a Parallel Plate Method", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.30, p.991, 1940.
  37. "Doctor August Herman Pfund, Ives Medalis for 1939", A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.30, pp.177-181, 1940.
  38. "Is Temperature a Basic Concept?", A. G. Worthing, in Temperature: Its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry, Reinhold Publishing Corporation, NY, 1941. pp.41-44. Also "Temperature Radiation Emissivities and Emittances", pp.1164-1187.
  39. "A Message from the President", Editorial Comment, A. G. Worthing, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol.32, Issue 1, pp.1-, 1942.

Publications - Books
  1. "The Diathermancy of Water to Solar Radiation", A. G. Worthing, A thesis for the degree of Bachelor of Arts, University of Wisconsin, 1904.
  2. "Physics of Light Production", Chapter I, and "Light Sources", Chapter II, in Illuminating Engineering, Francis E. Cady and Henry B. Dates, editors, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1925.
  3. "A series of six radio talks on some high lights in modern physics (with select bibliographies)", Lee Paul Sieg and Archie G. Worthing, Publisher: Pittsburgh, 1925.
  4. "A series of nine radio talks on the origin and development of artificial light sources, the dynamo, and the steam engine", (University of Pittsburgh. Radio publication), A. G. Worthing, 1927.
  5. An Outline of Atomic Physics, Thomas H. Osgood, Arthur E. Ruark, Wilfred N. St. Peter, George A. Scott & Archie G. Worthing, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1933.
  6. Treatment of Experimental Data, Archie G. Worthing & Joseph G. Geffner, J. Wiley & Sons, Inc., NY, 1943.
  7. Heat, Archie G. Worthing & David Halliday, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1948, 522 pages, 245 illus.


References
  1. National in the World War - April 6 1917 - November 11 1918, General Electric Company, 1920, pp.268,285.
  2. "Archie Garfield Worthing", Who Was Who in America, Vol.II (1943-1950), The A. N. Marquis Company, Chicago, p.93.
  3. "Archie Garfield Worthing, 1881-1949", O. H. Blackwood, American Journal of Physics, Vol.17, pp.457-457, 1949.
  4. "Archie Garfield Worthing", The National Cyclopaedia of American Biography, James T. White & Co., 1956, Vol.41, pp.182-183.
  5. "Dr. A. G. Worthing, Author, Physicist - Professor at U. of Pittsburgh, Known for His Tungsten Research, Dies at 68", The New York Times, August 1 1949, p17 col.3.
  6. http://www.leighlarson.com/olive_w_larson.htm (Olive W Larson)
  7. http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~wifonddu/resources/cemeteries/oak_mtpleasant_rows.html (Worthing)
  8. http://www.witherbeena.org/newsletters/06%20fall/newsletter%20for%20web%20site%20WNA%20Fall06v08lr.pdf (page 7, article by Ed Zimmer)
  9. http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~wigrant/bioindex.htm (Erasmus Witherbee)
  10. http:/ftp.us-census.org/pub/usgenweb/census/wi/grant/1900/_indx-w.txt (Witherbee)
  11. http://members.fortunecity.com/heselschwerdt/html/fam04067.html (Witherbee)
  12. http:www.usgwarchives.net/wi/cemetery/fonddulac-oakfieldtwp-mountpleasant.html (Worthing, tombstone photographs)